| Name | City | State | IG Followers | Average | IG Handle | Seed | Region | |
| East Village Pizza | New York | NY | 332,000 | 24,565 | 178,283 | eastvillagepizza | 1 | Bruins |
| Roberta’s | New York | NY | 121,000 | 21,805 | 71,403 | robertaspizza | 1 | Rangers |
| Lucali | Brooklyn | NY | 115,000 | 8,798 | 61,899 | lucali_bk | 1 | Islanders |
| Best Pizza Williamsburg | Brooklyn | NY | 108,000 | 6,307 | 57,154 | bestpizza33 | 1 | Whalers |
| Emmy Squared | Brooklyn | NY | 76,500 | 2,391 | 39,446 | emmysquaredpizza | 1 | Patriots |
| L & B Spumoni Gardens | Brooklyn | NY | 21,100 | 54,425 | 37,763 | lbspumonigardens | 1 | Jets |
| Lil Frankie’s | New York | NY | 71,200 | 3,570 | 37,385 | lilfrankies | 1 | Giants |
| Prince St | New York | NY | 59,400 | 3,319 | 31,360 | psp_nyc | 1 | Knicks |
| Di Fara | Brooklyn | NY | 29,600 | 26,172 | 27,886 | difarapizzanyc | 2 | Knicks |
| Artichoke Basille’s | New York | NY | 31,500 | 23,608 | 27,554 | artichokepizzaaz | 2 | Giants |
| Rubirosa | New York | NY | 45,700 | 5,371 | 25,536 | rubirosa_nyc | 2 | Jets |
| Frank Pepe | New Haven | CT | 24,600 | 24,848 | 24,724 | frankpepepizza | 2 | Patriots |
| Joe’s Pizza | New York | NY | 41,900 | 1,985 | 21,943 | joespizzanyc | 2 | Whalers |
| Patsy’s | New York | NY | 12,300 | 30,969 | 21,635 | patsyspizzeria | 2 | Islanders |
| Cuts and Slices | Brooklyn | NY | 37,200 | 2,992 | 20,096 | cutsandslicesnyc | 2 | Rangers |
| Vinnie’s Brooklyn | Brooklyn | NY | 34,700 | 4,775 | 19,738 | vinniesbrooklyn | 2 | Bruins |
| Town Spa | Stoughton | MA | 19,215 | 19,216 | 19,216 | Faceebook | 3 | Bruins |
| Lombardi’s | New York | NY | 5,673 | 32,446 | 19,060 | lombardis_pizza_nyc | 3 | Rangers |
| Coppa | Boston | MA | 31,500 | 4,471 | 17,986 | coppaboston | 3 | Islanders |
| Mama’s Too | New York | NY | 34,000 | 627 | 17,314 | mamas_too | 3 | Whalers |
| Scarr’s | New York | NY | 32,700 | 1,199 | 16,950 | scarrspizza | 3 | Patriots |
| Bar | New Haven | CT | 15,600 | 16,887 | 16,244 | bar_newhaven | 3 | Jets |
| Una Pizza Napolitina | New York | NY | 26,800 | 592 | 13,696 | unapizzanapoletena | 3 | Giants |
| Williamsburg Pizza | New York | NY | 24,300 | 2,491 | 13,396 | williamsburgpizza | 3 | Knicks |
| Ribalta | New York | NY | 14,700 | 11,415 | 13,058 | ribaltapizza | 4 | Knicks |
| Area Four | Boston | MA | 19,600 | 6,035 | 12,818 | areafour | 4 | Giants |
| Zuppardi’s | New Haven | CT | 5,410 | 19,055 | 12,233 | zuppardisapizza | 4 | Jets |
| Keste | New York | NY | 10,600 | 13,188 | 11,894 | 4 | Patriots | |
| Pauli Gee’s | Brooklyn | NY | 21,700 | 2,052 | 11,876 | pauliegeee | 4 | Whalers |
| Regina | Boston | MA | 7,247 | 15,686 | 11,467 | reginapizzeria | 4 | Islanders |
| Slab Portland | Portland | ME | 12,000 | 10,284 | 11,142 | slabportland | 4 | Rangers |
| Otto | Portland | ME | 8,248 | 13,978 | 11,113 | ottoportland | 4 | Bruins |
| Biga Bite | Manhattan | NY | 17,900 | 1,036 | 9,468 | biga_bite | 5 | Bruins |
| Federal Hill Pizza | Warren | RI | 10,200 | 8,482 | 9,341 | federalhillpizza | 5 | Rangers |
| Krust | Middletown | CT | 6,235 | 12,299 | 9,267 | krustpizzabar | 5 | Islanders |
| Rail Trail | Hudson | MA | 6,955 | 11,482 | 9,219 | railtrailflatbreadco | 5 | Whalers |
| Antonios | Amherst | MA | 2,112 | 16,077 | 9,095 | antoniospizza | 5 | Patriots |
| L’industrie Pizzeeria | Brooklyn | NY | 17,000 | 1,098 | 9,049 | lindustriebk | 5 | Jets |
| 2 Bros | New York | NY | – | 14,717 | 7,359 | 5 | Giants | |
| American Flatbread | Waitsfield | VT | 1,968 | 12,308 | 7,138 | americanflatbread | 5 | Knicks |
| Colony Grill | Stamford | CT | 7,259 | 6,941 | 7,100 | colonygrill | 6 | Knicks |
| Pugsley Pizza | Bronx | NY | 8,092 | 5,570 | 6,831 | pugsleypizza | 6 | Giants |
| Juliana’s | Brooklyn | NY | 9,242 | 4,418 | 6,830 | julianaspizza | 6 | Jets |
| OPS | Brooklyn | NY | 12,800 | 544 | 6,672 | opsnyc | 6 | Patriots |
| Piecasso | Stowe | VT | 2,412 | 10,786 | 6,599 | piecasso | 6 | Whalers |
| Table 87 | Brooklyn | NY | 10,400 | 2,610 | 6,505 | table87_ | 6 | Islanders |
| Emmett’s NYC | New York | NY | 10,800 | 1,931 | 6,366 | emmettsnyc | 6 | Rangers |
| Lynnwood Café | Randolph | MA | 1,431 | 10,932 | 6,182 | lynwoodcafe | 6 | Bruins |
| Montilios | Quincy | MA | 4,566 | 7,783 | 6,175 | montilios | 7 | Bruins |
| Easy Pie | Revere | MA | 6,247 | 5,655 | 5,951 | theeasypie | 7 | Rangers |
| Parker Pie Co | West Glover | VT | 2,167 | 9,368 | 5,768 | parkerpieco | 7 | Islanders |
| Red Rose | Springfield | MA | 169 | 11,173 | 5,671 | redrosepizzeria | 7 | Whalers |
| Sauce Pizzeria | New York | NY | 10,400 | 823 | 5,612 | saucepizzerianyc | 7 | Patriots |
| Modern APizza | New Haven | CT | 4,809 | 6,204 | 5,507 | modernapizza | 7 | Jets |
| Posto | Somerville | MA | 7,738 | 3,073 | 5,406 | postoboston | 7 | Giants |
| Providence Coal Fired | Providence | RI | 2,247 | 7,522 | 4,885 | provcoalfirepizza | 7 | Knicks |
| Brewer’s Fork | Charlestown | MA | 6,115 | 3,492 | 4,804 | brewers_fork | 8 | Knicks |
| Montes | Portland | ME | 6,112 | 3,272 | 4,692 | montesfinefoods | 8 | Giants |
| Dani’s House of Pizza | Kew Gardens, | NY | 6,032 | 3,159 | 4,596 | danishouseofpizza | 8 | Jets |
| Village Square | New York | NY | 8,316 | 495 | 4,406 | villagesquarepizza | 8 | Patriots |
| Volturno Pizza | Worcester | MA | 3,307 | 5,502 | 4,405 | volturnopizza | 8 | Whalers |
| Salty Pig | Boston | MA | 4,319 | 4,487 | 4,403 | saltypigboston | 8 | Islanders |
| Pizza J | Providence | RI | 4,064 | 4,664 | 4,364 | pizzajpvd | 8 | Rangers |
| Al Forno | Providence | RI | 4,031 | 4,665 | 4,348 | alfornorestaurantprovidence | 8 | Bruins |
| figidini | Providence | RI | 5,634 | 3,019 | 4,327 | figidini | 9 | Bruins |
| Johns Bleeker | New York | NY | 4,383 | 4,232 | 4,308 | bleeckerstpizza | 9 | Rangers |
| Folinos | Shelburne | VT | 3,768 | 4,705 | 4,237 | folinopizza | 9 | Islanders |
| Caserta | Providence | RI | 2,979 | 5,019 | 3,999 | caserta_pizzeria | 9 | Whalers |
| Da Legna | New Haven | CT | 7,055 | 914 | 3,985 | da_legna | 9 | Patriots |
| Grimaldi’s | Brooklyn | NY | 7,665 | 147 | 3,906 | grimaldispizza | 9 | Jets |
| Stoked | Brookline | MA | 3,970 | 3,809 | 3,890 | stokedpizza | 9 | Giants |
| Montes | Lynn | MA | 3,865 | 3,865 | 3,865 | 9 | Knicks | |
| Baldie’s Pizzeria | Lakeville | MA | 1,727 | 6,002 | 3,865 | baldiescraftpizzeria | 10 | Knicks |
| Hot Box | Somerville | MA | 7,206 | 308 | 3,757 | oathpizza | 10 | Giants |
| Denino’s | Staten Island | NY | 4,537 | 2,946 | 3,742 | deninos_greenwichvillage | 10 | Jets |
| Stanziatos | Danbury | CT | 3,908 | 3,467 | 3,688 | stanziatos | 10 | Patriots |
| Semolina Kitchen | Medford | MA | 5,875 | 1,382 | 3,629 | semolinakitchen | 10 | Whalers |
| NY Pizza Suprema | New York | NY | 3,859 | 3,158 | 3,509 | nypizzasuprema | 10 | Islanders |
| Fellini | Providence | RI | 2,532 | 3,874 | 3,203 | fellini.pizzeria | 10 | Rangers |
| Charcoal Guido’s | Waltham | MA | 1,836 | 4,518 | 3,177 | charcoalguidos | 10 | Bruins |
| Crisp | Osterville | MA | 2,820 | 3,261 | 3,041 | crispflatbread | 11 | Bruins |
| Ciao | Chelsea | MA | 3,365 | 2,496 | 2,931 | ciaopizzaandpasta | 11 | Rangers |
| Angela’s | Saugus | MA | 973 | 4,784 | 2,879 | angelascoalfiredpizza | 11 | Islanders |
| Capizzi | New York | NY | 4,147 | 1,605 | 2,876 | capizzinyc | 11 | Whalers |
| Tipo | Portland | ME | 3,780 | 1,849 | 2,815 | tipomaine | 11 | Patriots |
| Ember | Harwich Port | MA | 2,597 | 3,022 | 2,810 | embercoalfirepizzawings | 11 | Jets |
| A3 | Kingston | MA | 3,346 | 2,132 | 2,739 | a3kingston | 11 | Giants |
| Picco Boston | Boston | MA | 2,699 | 2,729 | 2,714 | piccoboston | 11 | Knicks |
| Harry’s Italian | New York | NY | 3,972 | 1,291 | 2,632 | harrysitalian | 12 | Knicks |
| Totonnos | Brooklyn | NY | 1,593 | 3,542 | 2,568 | totonnos | 12 | Giants |
| Newtowne Grill | Cambridge | MA | 930 | 4,133 | 2,532 | newtownecambridge | 12 | Jets |
| Joe & Pat’s | Staten Island | NY | 4,198 | 779 | 2,489 | joeeandpats | 12 | Patriots |
| Luigi’s | Brooklyn | NY | 4,380 | 532 | 2,456 | luigispizzaparkslope | 12 | Whalers |
| 16c | Quincy | MA | 1,575 | 3,309 | 2,442 | 16crestaurant | 12 | Islanders |
| The Corner Grill | Worcester | MA | 1,386 | 3,389 | 2,388 | cornergrilleworcester | 12 | Rangers |
| Village Pizza | Greenfield | MA | 817 | 3,934 | 2,376 | villagepizzagreenfield | 12 | Bruins |
| Bufalina | Guilford | CT | 1,565 | 2,974 | 2,270 | bufalina_ct | 13 | Bruins |
| Mariano’s | Pepperell | MA | 1,022 | 3,485 | 2,254 | marianosristorante | 13 | Rangers |
| Umberto | Boston | MA | 1,419 | 2,915 | 2,167 | galleriaumberto | 13 | Islanders |
| Avvio | Cranston | RI | 1,727 | 2,591 | 2,159 | avvioristroante | 13 | Whalers |
| Santarpio’s | East Boston | MA | 2,881 | 1,285 | 2,083 | santarpiospizza | 13 | Patriots |
| Wood & Fire | Melrose | MA | 1,691 | 2,387 | 2,039 | woodandfiremelrose | 13 | Jets |
| Zeneli | New Haven | CT | 1,984 | 1,840 | 1,912 | zeneli_pizzeria | 13 | Giants |
| Crisp | Walpole | MA | 1,039 | 2,700 | 1,870 | crispwalpole | 13 | Knicks |
| Louie & Ernie’s | New York | NY | 1,572 | 2,144 | 1,858 | louieandernies | 14 | Knicks |
| Sasso’s | Torrington | CT | 940 | 2,763 | 1,852 | sassoscoalfiredpizza | 14 | Giants |
| Poopsie’s | Pembroke | MA | – | 3,580 | 1,790 | 14 | Jets | |
| John And Maria’s | East Haven | CT | 1,016 | 2,559 | 1,788 | johnandmariaspizza | 14 | Patriots |
| Casa Pizzeria | Ludlow | MA | 1,002 | 2,559 | 1,781 | casa_pizzerie_ludlow_ma | 14 | Whalers |
| Florina Pizza | Boston | MA | 2,554 | 614 | 1,584 | florinapizza | 14 | Islanders |
| Tapestry | Boston | MA | 2,294 | 837 | 1,566 | tapestryboston | 14 | Rangers |
| Ernesto’s | Boston | MA | 1,523 | 1,523 | 1,523 | Faceebook | 14 | Bruins |
| Louie’s | Woburn | MA | 928 | 2,114 | 1,521 | louiespizzawoburn | 15 | Bruins |
| Sally’s | New Haven | CT | 1,635 | 1,307 | 1,471 | sallysapizza | 15 | Rangers |
| Dacoopas | East Boston | MA | 204 | 2,663 | 1,434 | dacoopaspizza | 15 | Islanders |
| Real Gusto | Medford | MA | 624 | 2,173 | 1,399 | realitaliangusto | 15 | Whalers |
| Quattro | Boston | MA | 386 | 2,293 | 1,340 | quattronorthend | 15 | Patriots |
| Dragon Pizza | Somerville | MA | 1,710 | 535 | 1,123 | dragonpizzasomerville | 15 | Jets |
| Locale | Boston | MA | 1,530 | 645 | 1,088 | localeboston | 15 | Giants |
| Denly Gardens | Weymouth | MA | 77 | 1,910 | 994 | denly_walpole | 15 | Knicks |
| Volo | Swampscott | MA | 1,110 | 876 | 993 | volopizza | 16 | Knicks |
| Sal & Carmine | New York | NY | 414 | 1,501 | 958 | sal_and_carmines | 16 | Giants |
| Max & Leo’s | Newton | MA | 801 | 1,079 | 940 | maxandleos | 16 | Jets |
| Rosie’s | Braintree | MA | – | 1,478 | 739 | 16 | Patriots | |
| Pizza by Rocco | Natick | MA | 819 | 372 | 596 | pizza_by_rocco | Play in 2 | Whalers |
| Café Sorelli | Woburn | MA | 578 | 578 | 578 | Play in 3 | Giants | |
| Pinos | Brighton | MA | 188 | 701 | 445 | official_pinospizza | Play in 4 | Islanders |
| Amore Pizza | Flushing | NY | – | 845 | 423 | Play in 1 | Bruins | |
| Nolita | New York | NY | 648 | 97 | 373 | nolitapizzanyc | Play in 4 | Islanders |
| Arturo’s | New York | NY | – | 742 | 371 | Play in 3 | Giants | |
| Frankie Slice | Peabody | MA | 278 | 406 | 342 | frankieslicepizza | Play in 2 | Whalers |
| NY Pizza W. Bridgewater | West Bridgewater | MA | 167 | 215 | 191 | nypizzawestbridgewater | Play in 1 | Bruins |
